Skip to content
Hey HollyRegister your interest

AI receptionist vs answering service.

Missing calls while you're on a job? You have four choices: an AI receptionist, a human answering service, your own receptionist, or voicemail. Here's a fair, plain comparison, so you can pick what suits your trade.

  • AIanswers and books the job
  • Call centrea person takes a message
  • Voicemailthe caller waits for you

The short answer

An answering service puts a real person on your phone, usually to take a message, and charges per call, per minute or by the month. An AI receptionist answers every call itself, day and night, and a good one books the job straight into your diary. It’s usually a monthly plan, often with a set number of minutes, and some also charge per call. Your own receptionist does the most but costs a salary. Voicemail costs nothing, but nobody answers.

Updated November 2026

Side by side

The same six questions for each option. Scroll the table sideways on a phone.

AI receptionist, answering service, your own receptionist and voicemail compared
Compared onAI receptionist, like HollyHuman answering serviceYour own receptionistVoicemail
When calls are answeredStraight away, day and night, bank holidays tooDepends on the plan. Some cover evenings and weekends, some charge more for themTheir working hours, minus breaks, holidays and sick daysNever answered. The caller hears your message
How you payUsually a monthly plan. Holly will be £79 a month with 300 minutes of calls included, no contractPer call, per minute, or a monthly bundle of callsA salary, plus employer's National Insurance, pension and holidayUsually included with your phone
Booking jobs into your diaryYes. Holly offers times you're actually free and books the jobSome can, often on a dearer plan. Many take a messageYes, if they can see your diaryNo
Knowing your tradeKnows your services, areas, working days and what she may say about prices, because you tell herWorks from the notes you give them, often while answering for many businessesLearns your business over timeNone
What callers hearA friendly British voice that says it's an AI assistantA real person, answering in your business nameA real person who knows your businessYour recorded greeting, then a beep
EmergenciesPut through to your mobile. If you miss it, you get a text and the caller is told when to expect youCan usually pass a message on, or put the call throughCan ring you or come and find youWait until you listen to your messages

AI receptionist vs answering service

Both do the same basic job: they pick up when you can’t, so the caller isn’t left with voicemail. The difference is who answers, and how much they can do once they have.

What an answering service does well

A human answering service gives your callers a real person, answering in your business name. For a caller who just wants to leave their details, that works well. Most services take a message and send it on to you by email or text. Some can put calls through to you or book appointments, often on a dearer plan. For example, ReceptionHQ’s appointment booking plan starts at £30 a month plus VAT (ReceptionHQ, checked November 2026).

The catch for a busy trade is the bill. Most services charge for every call or every minute, so a good week costs more. Our guide to what a telephone answering service costs in the UK has the real prices.

Where an AI receptionist does more

An AI receptionist answers straight away, day and night, bank holidays included. Holly is built for trades, so she asks the questions you would ask. A burst pipe is not a quote for a new bathroom. She checks the caller’s postcode is in an area you cover, offers times you’re actually free and books the job into your diary. You get a text summary the moment the call ends, with one tap to ring back.

AI receptionists aren’t always a flat fee, so check what’s included. Many are a monthly plan with a set number of minutes, and a busy month can still cost more. For example, Perfect Reception’s AI answering starts at £49.95 a month plus VAT for 100 minutes, then 50p a minute (Perfect Reception, checked November 2026). Answer.co.uk’s AI receptionist starts at £10 a month plus 85p a call (Answer.co.uk, checked November 2026).

Holly is £79 a month with 300 minutes of calls included, with no contract, so you can cancel any time. That’s £948 a year (12 times £79). See Holly’s pricing.

Where a person still wins

Be honest with yourself about your callers. Some people would always rather speak to a person, and an AI receptionist won’t change that. Holly tells every caller she’s an AI assistant at the start of the call. A person can also cope with the odd, unusual call more easily. If most of your calls are complicated conversations rather than bookings and enquiries, a human service may suit you better.

AI receptionist vs human receptionist

Your own receptionist is the gold standard. They learn your business, know your regular customers and can do your paperwork between calls. But they cost a salary, they work set hours, and when they’re on a break or on holiday, the phone still rings.

Receptionist salary in the UK

The National Careers Service puts a receptionist’s average salary at £21,000 a year to start and £25,000 with experience, for 37 to 40 hours a week (National Careers Service, checked November 2026). The legal minimum has risen since: from April 2026, the National Living Wage is £12.71 an hour for workers aged 21 and over (GOV.UK, checked November 2026).

Our sum: 37.5 hours a week for 52 weeks at £12.71 comes to about £24,785 a year. On top, an employer pays National Insurance at 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year (GOV.UK, checked November 2026), which adds about £2,968. That’s around £27,750 a year, roughly £2,300 a month, before pension, holiday cover and sick pay.

Set against that, Holly is £79 a month, or £948 a year. And one receptionist only covers their own hours. A week has 168 hours, and a full-time receptionist works about 37.5 of them, so answering every hour would take roughly four and a half full-time people (168 divided by 37.5), before holidays and sickness. Our estimate at the £21,000 starting salary (National Careers Service, checked November 2026): about £94,500 a year in wages alone.

When an AI receptionist makes more sense

Most sole traders and small trade firms don’t need someone at a desk all day. They need the phone answered when they’re up a ladder or under a sink, and the job booked in. That’s exactly what Holly does, evenings and weekends included, for £79 a month rather than a wage. If you also need help with invoices and post, a person (perhaps part-time) may still be worth it, with Holly covering the calls they can’t take.

And what about voicemail?

Voicemail is free and always on. But it only works if the caller is happy to leave a message and wait. Someone with water coming through the ceiling, or a door they can’t lock, will usually ring the next number on the list. And when you do listen to your messages, you still have to call everyone back to find out what they want.

If voicemail is all you have now, Holly is the step up: every call answered and the details sent to you by text. Read about getting a text after every missed call or after-hours call answering.

Which should you choose?

Choose a human answering service if

  • your callers expect a real person every time
  • you mostly need messages taken, and you’re happy to pay per call or per minute

Choose your own receptionist if

  • you have an office, visitors and paperwork as well as calls
  • you can cover a salary, National Insurance and holidays

Choose an AI receptionist if

  • you miss calls because you’re working, not because you’re short of staff
  • you want jobs booked into your diary, not just messages
  • you want evenings, weekends and bank holidays covered for £79 a month, not a wage

See how Holly works, step by step, or how she handles calls for your trade:

Questions about choosing

What is the difference between an AI receptionist and an answering service?

An answering service is usually a team of people at a call centre who answer your calls and take a message. An AI receptionist is a smart assistant that answers your calls itself, in your business name. A good one, like Holly, can also check the caller is in your area and book the job into your diary.

Is an AI receptionist better than a human receptionist?

Not in every way. A person can greet visitors, do your paperwork and handle unusual calls. An AI receptionist answers every call at once, day and night, for a monthly plan instead of a salary. For a trade that mainly needs the phone answered and jobs booked, an AI receptionist is often the better fit.

What is a live call answering service?

It means a real person answers your calls live, rather than a recorded message or voicemail. Most live services take a message and send it to you. Some can put the call through to you or book appointments, often for an extra charge.

Do answering services still exist?

Yes. Plenty of UK companies still offer human call answering, usually charged per call, per minute or as a monthly bundle. AI receptionists are a newer choice that does a similar job in a different way.

Will my customers mind talking to an AI?

Some people would rather speak to a person, and that's fair. Holly says she's an AI assistant at the start of every call, then gets on with helping. Most callers simply want someone to pick up, be friendly and sort out what they need.

Try the AI receptionist built for trades.

We're opening to UK trades soon, at £79 a month with a 7-day free trial to hear Holly take real calls. Register your interest and be among the first to know.